Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Westerville OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Ohio

Best Pizza in Westerville OH (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

202 Views

My stomach has been rumbling ever since I heard about all the renowned pizza places in the area. And I’m happy to report that after visiting 12 of them, I think I found the absolute best!

I’m no stranger to amazing pizza. I’ve traveled around the world trying different recipes, crust types and topping combinations. It’s been my mission to find the most flavorful and succulent slices out there – and you won’t be disappointed with Westerville’s options.

In this article, I’ll share with you my findings on the best pizza places in Westerville OH. With a little humor and wit, join me on my quest for deliciousness!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Ohio

#1 Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta House

The atmosphere at Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta House is quite cozy and inviting. There’s something special about the wood-fired oven and the rustic decor that makes you feel like you’re in a traditional Italian pizza joint.

The pizza at Pasquale’s is some of the best I’ve ever tasted. The crust is crispy and the sauce is flavorful, with a hint of garlic and oregano that just elevates the overall experience. The cheese melts perfectly over top and every bite packs a punch of flavor. From classic pepperoni to specialty pies, there’s something for everyone to enjoy here.

The pastas at Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta House are also divine! Whether it’s spaghetti or ravioli or anything in between, each dish has been carefully cooked to perfection – the sauces are rich, flavorful and just downright delicious.

All in all, I must say that Pasquale’s Pizza & Pasta House is one of the best pizza places I’ve come across in my travels. With great food, incredible service and an inviting atmosphere, this place simply can’t be beat when it comes to pizza!

If you’re willing to go an extra 5 miles, you can get to 23 more pizza places in Columbus!

#2 Antonio’s

On my visit, I was immediately struck by the inviting and cozy atmosphere of the restaurant. The decor had a classic Italian vibe and the staff were friendly and welcoming.

The menu had plenty of different varieties and styles of pizza to choose from, so it was hard to decide. Ultimately I decided to go with the signature Antonio’s Special: a thin crust pizza topped with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms and onions. It was absolutely delicious!

The crust was perfectly crisp while still having a lightness that melted in my mouth. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, complementing each other well.

I would recommend checking out Antonio’s if you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Westerville OH! You won’t be disappointed!

#3 Giammarco’s Italian Restaurant

As soon as I walked in the door, I was overwhelmed by the amazing smells emanating from all around me. From the wood-fired oven to the freshly prepared dough, Giammarco’s was an olfactory paradise!

The pizza itself didn’t disappoint either – I tried an array of different pies and each one had a unique flavor profile that left me wanting more. The crust was light and crispy while still holding up to my generous toppings. And the cheese? Oh man, the cheese! It was creamy, salty and melted perfectly with every bite.

But what really sets Giammarco’s apart is their attention to detail. Whether you’re getting a classic Margarita or something more creative like a fig-and-prosciutto pizza, you can rest assured that it will be cooked to perfection using only fresh ingredients.

In conclusion, Giammarco’s Italian Restaurant truly has some of the best pizza in Westerville OH! So if you’re ever looking for a delicious slice – look no further than Giammarco’s!

#4 Carsonie’s Stromboli & Pizza

I first noticed the welcoming atmosphere and lively, enthusiastic staff. Then came the all-important pizza tasting. I was initially surprised by how good the crust was. It had a perfectly crunchy texture with just enough chewiness that made every bite delicious. The sauce was full of flavor and not overly sweet or too salty. The cheese was light and moist, and it melted nicely on top of each piece.

Toppings were varied with creative combinations like pepperoni, olives, mushrooms, and onions. All the ingredients tasted fresh and the combination of flavors made for a unique experience that kept me coming back for more slices!

I’m happy to report that Carsonie’s Stromboli & Pizza have earned my vote as the best pizza in Westerville OH! Their delicious food coupled with their friendly service make them an easy pick when you’re looking for some great local pizza!

#5 Cardinal Pizza

I stopped by Cardinal Pizza to try their famous specialty pizzas and they did not disappoint! The crust was cooked perfectly– golden brown on the outside and warm and chewy on the inside. All of their fresh toppings were flavorful and abundant, making for a truly delicious pizza experience.

The atmosphere at Cardinal Pizza was also very inviting, with its cozy seating area where I could relax while enjoying my meal. The friendly staff took great care of me and went out of their way to help me find just the right pizza for my tastes.

It’s easy to see why Cardinal Pizza has been such a popular spot among local pizza lovers. If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in Westerville OH, you should definitely make a stop at Cardinal Pizza!

#6 Classic Pizza

Every time I step in the restaurant, it feels like I’m stepping back into a classic pizzeria from the old-country. The aromas of garlic, herbs, and melted cheese make me salivate with anticipation for whatever delicious combination awaits me.

The pizza is cooked to perfection every single time! The crust is crisp on the outside and fluffy on the inside, while the flavor that lingers on my tongue never fails to leave me wanting more. Toppings are always fresh and generously portioned, adding just the right amount of savory goodness with each bite.

The atmosphere at Classic Pizza is always welcoming and inviting; they have an excellent selection of craft beers to pair with your pizza (which might be necessary if you order one of their monstrous two-topping pies). Service is unbeatable – friendly smiles, prompt delivery times – but it’s the pizza that really keeps me coming back for more.

I truly believe that Classic Pizza has some of the best pizza in Westerville OH – no matter how far I’ve traveled around the world, it will always be my go-to spot for delicious Italian-inspired cuisine.

#7 Classic Pizza

The first thing that grabbed my attention was their extensive menu. Every dish is loaded with delicious toppings, from traditional pepperoni and sausage to jalapenos and pineapple. It’s truly a feast for the eyes as well as the taste buds!

Their crust is thick and chewy with just the right amount of crunch. Plus, they use only fresh ingredients so you can always count on high quality pizza.

We tried several varieties including a veggie special – it was incredible! The cheese was melted to perfection and each topping added its own unique flavor to the overall dish.

Finally, no meal at Classic Pizza is complete without an order of their irresistible garlic knots! They are to die for and the perfect finish to your dining experience.

In conclusion, if you’re ever looking for the best pizza in Westerville OH, then look no further than Classic Pizza – you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 7 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Columbus!

#8 Minico’s Italian Restaurant

I sampled their cheese pizza, and it was a truly magical experience. The combination of perfectly cooked dough, the perfect amount of cheese and just the right amount of Italian herbs created a heavenly symphony on my taste buds.

The marinara sauce was spot-on as well – not too acidic and not too sweet. It had the perfect balance that I like in my pizza sauces. I was beyond impressed!

My experience at Minico’s didn’t end with just the amazing food. The atmosphere here is delightful and welcoming – you can tell that everyone here is passionate about pizza and loves serving their customers great food. It’s a refreshing change from restaurants who seem to be more focused on turning tables than providing an enjoyable dining experience.

If you’re looking for pizza in Westerville OH, look no further than Minico’s Italian Restaurant. The best pizza around!

#9 Time & Change

The atmosphere here is great. It’s got a good sports bar vibe, so if you’re looking for somewhere to watch a game, this is the spot for you! Plus, they serve alcohol (and hard liquor!). Who could ask for more?

But in the end, it’s all about the pizza. And Time & Change really knows how to make some delicious pies! The dough is always perfectly seasoned and cooked, not too crunchy or soggy. The toppings are also top-notch – always prepared with fresh vegetables and meats.

Unfortunately they don’t offer delivery, but trust me when I say that it’s worth the trip! And if you need an extra incentive to come by, they’ve got some tasty desserts as well.

So if you’re looking for the best pizza in Westerville OH, look no further than Time & Change!

#10 Gionino’s Pizzeria

When I first walked in, I was warmly greeted by the staff. The atmosphere was cozy and inviting, clearly designed to make customers feel right at home.

The menu had a great selection of pizzas, ranging from classic Italian-style pies to creative gourmet varieties. I decided to try the classic pepperoni pie, which did not disappoint! The crust was perfectly crisp and tasty, with just the right amount of cheese and toppings.

And don’t get me started on the sauce—it really stole the show! It had a perfect balance of sweet and spicy flavors that elevated my whole experience.

To top it all off, Gionino’s also has some great sides like garlic breadsticks and salads. It’s truly a one-stop shop for some of the best pizza in Westerville OH!

#11 Fazoli’s

I’ve tasted pizza in Rome, Paris, Sicily, and even the far-off deserts of Morocco. But none of them compares to the deliciousness of Fazoli’s pizza!

The thin crust is just crunchy enough, yet still delightfully soft. The sauce is tangy and flavorful with a touch of sweetness that rounds out the flavor perfectly. The cheese is melted to bubbly perfection and blended nicely with all the other ingredients. And don’t even get me started on the toppings – they are fresh and savory!

My last visit to Fazoli’s included a large pepperoni pizza along with an antipasto salad and garlic breadsticks – all prepared quickly and served at just the right temperature. Every bite was an adventure, leaving me wanting more!

If you’re looking for great pizza in Westerville OH, then look no further than Fazoli’s. I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

#12 Mellow Mushroom Columbus

My favorite dish was their signature white pizza, which was loaded with garlic, spinach, and feta cheese. The crust was perfectly thin yet crispy, and the toppings had just the right balance of flavors. I especially liked that the cheese wasn’t too heavy – it melted in your mouth!

The service at Mellow Mushroom Columbus is top-notch, as well. The staff are all very knowledgeable about what they’re serving and are quick to offer suggestions if you don’t know what to order. They also have a pleasant attitude and are all smiles when you enter the restaurant.

If you’re in Westerville OH looking for the best pizza around, look no further than Mellow Mushroom Columbus!