Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Yonkers NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Yonkers NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

306 Views

I’ve traveled all around the world tasting different pizzas, so you know I’m a real connoisseur when it comes to this delicious dish. Over the past couple of weeks I’ve tried twelvedifferent restaurants in Yonkers offering pizza and I have to say, some of them were surprisingly exceptional!

In this article, I’ll walk you through my full pizza experience – from the crusts to the sauces – and rank each place accordingly. It may seem overwhelming, but I promise, it’s an adventure worth taking! So let’s get started on our quest to finding the best pizza in Yonkers NY!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Raceway

I went to Raceway in search of the perfect slice and was not disappointed. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere, complete with smiling faces and delicious aromas of pizza fresh out of the oven.

The menu was expansive, offering a myriad of pizzas — from classic pepperoni to unique combinations like their ‘Taco Supreme’ with ricotta cheese, chorizo, diced tomatoes and jalapenos. I opted for the Classic Cheese Pizza — a perfect blend of cheese, tomatoes and herbs that had been baked to crispy perfection.

The pizza was simply divine! The crust was so perfectly thin and soft that I could just fold it up and eat it without worrying about toppings spilling everywhere. The cheese was gooey and flavorful, while the sauce added just enough acidity to keep everything in balance.

Raceway is certainly worth a visit if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience! With friendly service, great prices, a mouthwatering menu selection, and some of the best pizza in Yonkers NY here — you can’t possibly go wrong!

If you’re willing to go an extra 1 miles, you can get to 24 more pizza places in Mt Vernon!

#2 Capri Pizzeria

When I first stepped in, the place had a peaceful and inviting aura. The pizza dough was freshly made with local ingredients and they had a wide selection of pizzas to choose from.

The servers were friendly and attentive – they helped me find the perfect pie for my taste buds! After tasting it, I felt like I had died and gone to pizza heaven! The crust was the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, the sauce was flavorful and the cheese melted beautifully over the toppings. It was truly sublime!

Although their pizza is out of this world, Capri Pizzeria’s other dishes deserve recognition too. Their pasta dishes were cooked perfectly al dente and their salads were fresh and flavorful.

All in all, Capri Pizzeria is definitely one of my favorite places for a delicious slice of pie when I’m in Yonkers NY. Trust me when I say that you won’t regret giving them a try – this is truly some of the best pizza around!

#3 A & V Pizzeria

I’m not sure how they do it, but their pies are consistently amazing. The pizza crust is light and flaky, while the sauce and toppings have the perfect balance of flavor. I just can’t get enough!

The atmosphere at A & V Pizzeria is relaxed and welcoming. The staff always makes sure that you’re taken care of, whether you dine in or take out. And even though it’s a small storefront joint, they’ve got plenty of seating inside so you don’t have to worry about waiting for a table.

If I had to choose one pizza place in Yonkers NY, there’s no doubt that I’d pick A & V Pizzeria! They’ve definitely earned their spot as the best pizza in town!

#4 Gino’s Pizzeria

The first thing that caught my attention was the aroma of fresh baked pizza coming from the oven. The thin and delicate crust was perfectly crispy and delicious. The sauce was perfectly balanced with bold and flavorful spices, and topped with generous amounts of cheese—it’s no wonder this place is so popular!

The staff were incredibly friendly, always smiling and checking in to make sure my experience was top-notch. They even went above and beyond by offering me some of their signature garlic knots—absolutely divine!

And the prices? Perfectly reasonable considering the quality of ingredients they use. From what I can tell, Gino’s Pizzeria truly cares about giving their customers an unforgettable dining experience.

Overall, I’m happy to report that Gino’s Pizzeria passed my rigorous review with flying colors, proving why it has earned its reputation as having some of the best pizza in Yonkers NY! If you’re ever in town looking for a great slice, or even just a few garlic knots, I highly recommend Gino’s Pizzeria.

#5 John’s Pizza

The first thing I noticed when walking into John’s Pizza was the cozy, inviting atmosphere. The wait staff were friendly, accommodating and showed a real passion for their craft – the pizza making!

I then tried a slice of their signature ‘Johns Special’ – it had a delicious thin crust, fresh cheese, flavorful meat, and unique mix of spices. Needless to say…it was one of the BEST pizzas I’ve ever tasted! The perfect amount of sauce too – not too much and not too little.

On top of all that, they also offer up some creative specialty pies like the ‘fajita pizza’ (which my taste buds are still drooling over!). And their garlic knots are definitely worth trying too!

All in all, I’m giving John’s Pizza two thumbs up for serving up some of the best pizza in Yonkers NY. You won’t be disappointed if you’re craving great pizza with exceptional ingredients and attentive service – head on over to John’s Pizza today!

#6 Roma II Pizza

My first impression of Roma II Pizza was excellent – the atmosphere is warm, inviting, and they had a nice selection of Italian-inspired decor. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable and more than willing to answer any questions I had.

The pizza itself? Absolutely delicious! While some reviews have said the crust is too thin for their liking, I found it to be the perfect amount of crunchiness. The sauce was flavorful, and the cheese – oh man, was it good! All the ingredients blended together so nicely.

I also really enjoyed the variety of toppings that were available – from classic pepperoni and sausage to specialty combinations like Hawaiian and Greek-style pizzas. There’s something for everyone here at Roma II Pizza!

Overall, I can confidently say that this place serves up some of the best pizza in Yonkers NY. If you’re ever in town and looking for a great pizza spot, make sure you stop by Roma II Pizza!

#7 Silvio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

The moment I stepped into Silvio’s, I knew good pizza was on the way. The restaurant exuded warmth and comfort, from the picturesque murals of Italy to the cozy atmosphere. The staff was friendly and accommodating, ready to answer any questions I had about the menu.

I decided to try their signature dish—the classic margherita pizza. As soon as it arrived, I could tell this was some serious stuff! The dough was thin and golden-brown, with just enough crispness to make it perfect. As for the toppings: a generous helping of fresh mozzarella cheese and ripe tomatoes burst with flavor in every bite.

I also tried an order of garlic knots, which were soft and buttery beyond belief. They were so good that my taste buds did a happy dance!

Overall, if you’re looking for your next pizza destination in Yonkers NY, look no further than Silvio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria—it certainly has earned my seal of approval!

#8 Pizza Barn

I’ll never forget the first time I walked into Pizza Barn, it was like stepping into a pizza paradise! The atmosphere alone was enough to make me drool. The place was cozy and inviting, with a homey feel and wood paneling everywhere.

The menu was packed with an endless array of delicious options. They have everything from classic cheese pies to custom creations packed with all sorts of tasty toppings.

But the real star of this show is the pizza itself. Every single pie I’ve eaten here has been nothing short of spectacular. The crust is made from handmade dough which is deliciously thin and crispy on the outside but still light and fluffy when you bite into it. Then there’s the flavorful tomato sauce which is prepared fresh daily. And lastly, the topping selections are top-notch ranging from savory meats to freshly picked vegetables – all cooked to perfection!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Yonkers NY then look no further than Pizza Barn!

If you’re willing to go an extra 4 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in New Rochelle!

#9 Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

I was greeted by the friendly staff upon entering and shown to my table. My eyes were immediately drawn to the amazing array of ingredients available, allowing me to build my perfect pizza. I went with a classic margarita — tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, and garlic — as I wanted to get a true taste of what they offer here.

I was blown away! Every bite of the pizza was delicious, with the perfect combination of crunchy crust and gooey cheese. The accompanying marinara sauce added just the right amount of flavor and made me want to take another slice — or two.

All in all, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is a great spot for those looking for some of the best pizza in Yonkers NY. The atmosphere and service really add to the experience and make it an enjoyable place to visit time after time!

#10 Bella Rosa Pizzeria

The first thing that catches your eye when you walk in is the smell of delicious pizza. The counter-tops are lined with freshly made pies and the staff greet you with a friendly smile. No matter what kind of pizza you like – from cheese to pepperoni to the works – Bella Rosa Pizzeria has something for everyone!

The pizza was cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of crispiness on the crust and plenty of flavor. I particularly enjoyed their house special, which had a seafood twist on an old Italian classic. But in all honesty I couldn’t go wrong with any choice I made; every pie was top-notch!

And if you’re looking for something beyond pizza, they also have great salad choices and other Italian delights. Overall, Bella Rosa Pizzeria is an excellent spot for a night out or even just take-out! After tasting their exceptional creations, I can honestly say that it’s one of the best pizza places in Yonkers NY!

#11 Marcellino’s

To start, the decor is nothing short of phenomenal. It’s a cozy little joint with classic Italian vibes, and the red-checkered tablecloths just make me want to hang out for hours.

The pizza itself is definitely top notch. They use only the freshest ingredients and cook their pizzas to perfection in a stone oven that pumps out some seriously good pies. The crust is soft and flavorful, and the toppings are always cooked just right.

Their portions are also very generous for the price point – it’s almost enough for two meals! I’d recommend getting two pieces so you can savor every delicious bite of their Neopolitan-style pizzas.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Yonkers NY, Marcellino’s should be first on your list!

#12 Louie & Johnnie’s Ristorante Primavera

My quest to find the best pizza in Yonkers NY led me to Louie & Johnnie’s, and I was not disappointed. The atmosphere was cozy yet upscale, with a super friendly staff. The pizza itself was outstanding: thin crust, perfectly cooked with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Not too much – just enough to make it delicious. Plus, they offer unique topping options like artichoke hearts and spicy Italian sausage that make their pies truly stand out from the rest.

I have to say, I’m pretty impressed by what Louie & Johnnie’s has going on. I’d definitely give them five stars for their delicious pizza and great service! Highly recommend if you’re looking for a delicious slice of ‘za in Yonkers NY.

Best Thin Crust Pizza – Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

First of all, let’s talk about their vegetarian options. As a herbivore, I often find myself left with boring salads in most pizza joints. But at Frank Pepe’s, I was pleasantly surprised to find a variety of veggie toppings that not only satisfied my taste buds but also made me question my carnivorous instincts. From flavorful roasted peppers to hearty mushrooms, they know how to make a veggie pizza that even carnivores would drool over.

Now, let’s move on to the best part – dessert! Yes, you heard it right. Frank Pepe’s not only slays it in the pizza department but also offers a sinful selection of desserts. I highly recommend their Nutella pizza, which is basically a heavenly combination of warm pizza dough and a generous slather of Nutella. It’s like an edible hug for your taste buds!

As a tourist spot, Frank Pepe’s definitely stands out. Located in a charming part of town, it gives you that classic Italian pizzeria feel. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. It’s a great place to unwind after a long day of being a tourist, especially if you’re tired of eating hot dogs from street vendors.

Now, for the downside – they don’t accept reservations. I get it, they want to maintain their authentic pizzeria vibe, but as a hungry traveler who doesn’t like waiting, it can be a bit frustrating. But trust me, the wait is worth it!

All in all, Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana is a true gem for pizza lovers. With their exceptional thin crust pizza, delicious vegetarian options, indulgent desserts, and cozy ambiance, it’s a place that you shouldn’t miss when you’re in westchester ny, even if it means dealing with a little wait time.