Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Mcallen (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Texas

Best Pizza in Mcallen (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

160 Views

After searching for the best pizza in town, I’ve tried 12 places and am now ready to share my findings with you. But before we get into the details, let me take a moment to brag: I’m something of an expert on this stuff. After all, I’ve experienced first-hand what it’s like to sample pizza from around the world!

It’s time to find out if any of the pizzerias in Mcallen can live up to my high standards. I’m sure there’ll be plenty of laughter along the way as I give my humorous opinion on each one – so grab a slice and join me for a delicious ride!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Texas

#1 Gina’s Restaurant

My visit began with the delightful aroma of fresh ingredients, followed by a friendly smile from an attentive server. The owner, Gina herself, even came over to say hello!

When it came time to order my pizza, I was absolutely spoiled for choice. No matter what type of pizza you’re looking for – thin crust, deep dish, loaded with toppings – they have it all! After deciding on a delicious sausage and pepperoni pie, I eagerly awaited its arrival.

When the pizza arrived at my table, I could immediately tell that it was made with love and care. The sauce was perfectly balanced and the cheese was gooey and flavorful. The best part? The crust! It was light and crispy on the outside but still soft inside – a real treat.

To top off my experience at Gina’s Restaurant, the staff were incredibly friendly and made sure that I had everything I needed for an enjoyable meal. All in all, this place is definitely worth checking out if you’re ever in Mcallen looking for some of the best pizza around!

If you’re willing to go an extra 65 miles, you can get to 6 more pizza places in South Padre Island!

#2 Mama Mia Pizzeria

As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I knew I was in for a treat. The decor was classic Italian with vibrant colors and candlelit tables. The smells of garlic and oregano filled the air and my mouth began to water.

The wait staff were some of the friendliest people I have ever met! They recommended their signature Mama Mia pie which had layers of cheese and pepperoni – it tasted just like a pizza should! And the crust? Let me tell you, it was as if someone had sprinkled magic on top of it! Absolutely delicious!

I also sampled some of their other specialties such as the Garden Pizza made with mushrooms, bell peppers, onions and olives – just bursting with flavor! As if that wasn’t enough, they also offer calzones, salads and sandwiches.

Overall, Mama Mia Pizzeria was an incredible experience – from start to finish. Their pizza is truly scrumptious, beyond compare. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Mcallen then look no further than Mama Mia Pizzeria – you won’t be disappointed!

#3 Peter Piper Pizza

From the moment I stepped inside, I was impressed. The restaurant has a great atmosphere – perfect for watching sports with your friends or taking the kids out for some fun. And unbeatable bonus: they serve alcohol too!

The menu offers a wide selection of pizzas, and even has a kid’s menu, so everyone can find something they like. But the real winner here is their pizza. Every bite is bursting with flavor and it comes in all sorts of toppings to choose from. Their crust is also fantastic, it’s crispy on the outside but still soft and chewy on the inside – just how I like it!

One downside though: there’s no delivery service, so you have to visit them in person to get your pizza fix. But it’s worth it for some of the best pizza in Mcallen! Plus, why not turn it into an adventure and make a day out of it? With all the tourist attractions nearby, you won’t regret it.

If you’re ever craving pizza in Mcallen then Peter Piper Pizza is definitely worth checking out!

#4 Scalisi’s Chicago Pizza & More

My experience started out with the warm and inviting atmosphere. The family-style seating allows for groups of all sizes to enjoy the delicious pies that are cooked in a traditional Chicago deep dish style. I was delighted when I saw the variety of toppings available, from classic pepperoni to artichoke hearts and spinach.

The pizza itself was like no other. The dough was light, fluffy, and slightly crispy around the edges while the sauce and cheese were just right – not too overpowering but still flavorful. The crust was so good that I nearly licked my plate clean!

But what really sets Scalisi’s apart is their commitment to quality ingredients and artisan preparation techniques. Each ingredient is carefully chosen, and every pizza is baked to perfection in a stone oven to ensure an even heat distribution throughout each individual pie. The result? A pizza that’s truly mouthwatering!

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Mcallen, look no further than Scalisi’s Chicago Pizza & More! Trust me – this place won’t disappoint!

#5 Marco’s Pizza

I recently stopped in at Marco’s Pizza, and was amazed by the quality of their pizza. The crust was a perfect mix of chewy and crunchy, the toppings were fresh and flavorful, and the sauce had the perfect balance of sweetness and spiciness.

The service at Marco’s Pizza was also top-notch; my server was friendly and helpful, guiding me through the menu. It felt like I was getting a real taste of Mcallen!

Overall, if you’re looking for a great slice of pizza while in Mcallen, look no further than Marco’s Pizza. Even after visiting dozens of pizzerias around the world, I can honestly say that this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!

#6 Blue Onion

The restaurant has an inviting atmosphere, with its bright blue and white decor. The pizzas are served up on big metal pans, so they come out piping hot. I had the classic cheese pizza, and it was delicious – perfect crust, cheesy goodness, and a great sauce.

I also tried the pepperoni pizza, which was even better! The pepperoni was crunchy and flavorful, and went great with the other toppings.

But what really made this place stand out for me was their dessert selection. They offer calzones stuffed with sweet treats like marshmallows, chocolate chips, and cookies. I’m not normally one for sweets but these were amazing – buttery dough surrounding soft filling. Delicious!

Overall I’d highly recommend Blue Onion to anyone looking for the best pizza in Mcallen. Their inventive topping combinations make it worth a visit!

#7 Alejandro Bakery & Pizza Factory

The atmosphere is wonderful. The walls are covered with amazing art, and the staff is incredibly friendly. Plus, the jukebox keeps everyone singing along to some of their favorite tunes. It’s like being at a party!

As for their pizza, it’s simply divine. The crust has been cooked to perfection and the cheese melts in your mouth. Their pepperoni is top-notch, and their sausage is juicy and flavorful. Speaking of flavors, they have quite a few unique ones that I’ve never seen anywhere else – from Hawaiian style to Thai-inspired toppings.

Overall, this pizza place was well worth the visit! The food was some of the best I’ve had anywhere in Mcallen – definitely up there with the best pizza joints in Texas. If you’re looking for quality pizza at an affordable price, then Alejandro Bakery & Pizza Factory should be your top choice!

#8 Mama’s Pizzeria

The restaurant itself looks small and unassuming, but don’t be fooled; they’ve got some amazing pizzas. When I walked in, the smell of freshly baked pizza dough was everywhere. I was instantly hooked!

The staff was very accommodating and made sure that my order was taken care of quickly. I waited just a few minutes for my pizza to arrive, and it did not disappoint. The flavor was delicious and the portion size just right. It would have been nice to get more toppings, but overall the pizza was beyond satisfying.

I’m certain that Mama’s Pizzeria has the best pizza in Mcallen as far as quality, taste, and presentation go. If you’re looking for great pizza with a lot of local flair, you can’t go wrong with Mama’s Pizzeria!

If you’re willing to go an extra 115 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Corpus Christi!

#9 Extreme Pizza

I’ve tasted pizza from Rome to New York, but the pies at Extreme Pizza still reigns supreme. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy – not too doughy, yet still providing enough structural integrity to hold all that cheesy goodness without making a mess.

The toppings selection was impressive, with classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage, but also unusual combinations like BBQ pulled pork and pineapple! It’s easy to build your own creations here, or you can pick from their signature pizzas for something a little more adventurous.

The service was incredibly friendly and accommodating, the atmosphere was lively, and the prices were reasonable. With locations spread out across Mcallen, it’s easy to get your hands on the best pizza in town!

#10 Pizza Hut

The atmosphere is inviting and fun. The servers are friendly and attentive, always bringing out hot, delicious pizza in a timely manner.

The thin crust pizza is perfectly crispy, allowing for maximum flavor with each bite. The different handmade sauces give the pizzas an explosion of flavors. And their specialty toppings add just the right amount of spice to the pies.

As if the taste isn’t enough, Pizza Hut also offers great value for your money by providing large portions and reasonable prices.

Sadly, they don’t offer delivery, but that’s only minor criticism in my book. This is definitely worth the trip to Mcallen if you’re looking for great-tasting pizza!

#11 Papa Johns Pizza

It’s hard to find a single slice of pizza that stands out from the rest, but Papa Johns consistently has the best. The cheese is always gooey, and the toppings are generously distributed to make every bite a delight. You can also choose from a variety of crusts, so there’s something for everyone.

The staff is also very friendly and accommodating, which makes the whole experience even better. From recommending their favorite combinations to helping out with orders for large groups, their customer service really adds to the overall atmosphere.

Overall, if you’re looking for great pizza in Mcallen then Papa Johns Pizza needs to be at the top of your list. Their deliciousness combined with excellent service makes this pizzeria a must-try!

#12 Pizza Hut

The first thing that struck me when I entered the restaurant was the unmistakable smell of fresh-baked pizza. As I looked around, I noticed that each pizza was hand-tossed with precise accuracy in the air and crafted with care. Not to mention, there was a wide variety of toppings, including classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese, as well as exotic options like artichoke hearts and pineapple.

One thing that really impressed me about Pizza Hut was their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating, offering helpful suggestions on what type of pizza would best suit my tastes. And they weren’t wrong – my pizza was delicious! It had just the right amount of crunchy crust (they definitely don’t skimp on the dough!), juicy tomato sauce, flavorful cheese, and of course a generous helping of my chosen toppings.

All in all, Pizza Hut is certainly one of the best pizza places in Mcallen. If you’re looking for great tasting food at an affordable price, look no further!