Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in Jamestown NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in New York

Best Pizza in Jamestown NY (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

105 Views

I’ve been fortunate enough to try out some of the best pizza in the world and I’m excited to now become a part-time pizza critic of Jamestown NY! After tasting twelve different pizzas from local spots in town, I’m finally ready to tell you which one I’d recommend as the best pizza in Jamestown NY.

But first, let me set the scene: authentic Italian recipes, bubbly cheese, mouthwatering sauce, golden brown crusts…all baked to perfection! Now all that’s left is for you to decide which spot has the best slice! So just settle back on your couch and join me as I take you along my journey of finding the best pizza in Jamestown NY.

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of New York

#1 Elmo’s Pizza

From the second I walked in, I was in pizza heaven. The smell of the ovens and tantalizing pies made my mouth water and my stomach grumble with delight. The staff was friendly and attentive, giving me all the time and information needed to make an informed decision on what kind of pie I wanted.

The crust was delicious – crispy on the outside, but still light and airy. The cheese was perfectly melted with a super creamy texture that had me already asking for another slice before I finished the first! The selection of toppings is also outstanding, from traditional favorites like pepperoni, to more unusual combinations like pineapple, garlic, and jalapenos.

I highly recommend Elmo’s Pizza for anyone looking for the best pizza in Jamestown NY. Whether you’re looking for a classic combo or something new, you won’t be disappointed!

If you’re willing to go an extra 44 miles, you can get to 28 more pizza places in Erie!

#2 Lena’s Pizza

While this may sound like an obvious statement to some, I’m here to attest that the pizza at Lena’s is truly exceptional. The dough is perfectly crisp and the carefully crafted toppings are simply divine!

The atmosphere at Lena’s Pizza contributes significantly to its charm. Located in a popular tourist spot, it has become a bit of a local legend. On any given night you can find both locals and visitors alike dancing in the streets outside while their thin crust pizzas cook away inside.

Unfortunately, there isn’t delivery service for those of us who don’t want to get up and move around, but that’s really my only complaint! All-in-all this spot certainly deserves five stars from anyone who loves great pizza!

#3 Pace’s Pizzeria 🍕

I was skeptical at first, thinking that another small town pizzeria couldn’t possibly hold up to the high standards I’ve come to expect. Boy, was I wrong!

From the moment I stepped into Pace’s Pizzeria 🍕, I knew this place was special. The atmosphere was inviting and cozy—it reminded me of home. The staff was friendly and helpful and their knowledge of pizza toppings almost made me blush (a rare occurrence).

They don’t skimp on the ingredients either. All of their pizza is made with fresh, hand-picked produce which results in a delicious and flavorful experience. The crust is light but crispy, an absolute requirement for great pizza.

Even more impressive is their selection of unique toppings that you won’t find anywhere else! Whether it’s pineapple/ham combos or exotic meats like kangaroo, Pace has something special for everyone’s taste buds.

Overall, my experience at Pace’s Pizzeria 🍕 has been quite positive and I can confidently say that it’s some of the best pizza in Jamestown NY!

#4 Sauce

I was especially excited to find out that not only does Sauce serve alcohol, but it also has a kid’s menu. After my little ones were taken care of, my vegetarian friends found plenty of options to choose from.

The real highlight for me was the insanely good desserts! I’ve never had a better vegan brownie – and I’ve tried a lot!

Unfortunately, there is no delivery service here. But if you’re already in town and looking for great pizza and a nice tourist spot, then definitely check out Sauce. You won’t regret it!

If you’re willing to go an extra 62 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Buffalo!

#5 The Perfect Pizza Restaurant

As soon as I walked in, I knew this place was something special. The restaurant had a lively atmosphere and the staff were friendly and helpful.

The pizza itself was excellent. The dough was light and airy with just enough crunch. The tomato sauce was flavorful and not too sweet or acidic which complimented the toppings perfectly. The cheese melted perfectly on top of the crust and there were plenty of toppings to choose from.

My personal favorite pizza at The Perfect Pizza Restaurant is their classic pepperoni pie. This pizza is made with freshly grated mozzarella cheese, homemade tomato sauce and paper-thin slices of pepperoni that are evenly distributed throughout each slice. It was absolutely delicious!

I would highly recommend visiting The Perfect Pizza Restaurant in Jamestown NY if you’re looking for some of the best pizza around!

#6 Honest John’s Pizzeria Fairmount

I was really impressed with their selection of toppings, from classic pepperoni and cheese to creative combos like pineapple and ham. Their dough is perfectly cooked, with just the right amount of crunch, and their sauce has a great balance of tartness and sweetness.

The atmosphere is great, too—it’s family-friendly and they have large tables so you can share pizza with your friends. Plus, their staff are really friendly, so it’s a great place for groups.

It’s easy to see why Honest John’s Pizzeria Fairmount is one of the most popular pizza restaurants in Jamestown NY—their pizzas are truly top-notch! If you’re looking for an unforgettable pizza experience, then you should definitely check out Honest John’s Pizzeria Fairmount!

#7 Honest John’s Pizzeria Second St

First off, the crust is the perfect combination of thin and crispy. It has the perfect crunch and flavor that always hits the spot. And there’s no shortage of toppings – they offer a wide variety to choose from. Whether it be classic pepperoni or something more unusual like artichoke, there’s always something new to try!

The atmosphere in Honest John’s is also perfect for any pizza enthusiast. They have large TVs showing all the big games and an old-school jukebox that plays classic tunes all day long. Plus, their waitstaff are incredibly friendly and accommodating, making sure everyone has a good time while they enjoy their pizza.

But the best part about Honest John’s Pizzeria Second St is definitely their amazing housemade cheese blend! It’s absolutely out of this world and takes your slice to an entirely new level. Even as a traveling food critic, I feel it’s my duty to declare this place as having some of the best pizza in Jamestown NY!

If you’re willing to go an extra 66 miles, you can get to 27 more pizza places in Amherst!

#8 Tasta Pizza

Upon walking in, I was immediately greeted with the aroma of freshly baked pizza dough wafting through the air. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and it felt like I was home.

The menu featured a variety of delicious options including vegetarian, meat-lovers, and Hawaiian pizzas. To sample their selection, I ordered a Personal Gourmet Pizza which included five different toppings including pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, olives, and peppers.

The pizza itself was cooked perfectly – the crust had just the right amount of crunchiness to it and it had this amazing cheese blend that melted on your tongue. The tomato sauce underneath had just enough flavor to make each bite enjoyable without overpowering everything else. And the toppings were cooked to perfection!

To top it all off, Tasta Pizza also has an excellent selection of beverages to choose from – whether you’re looking for a cold beer or a glass of wine they have something for everyone.

I must say that Tasta Pizza did not disappoint – it truly is the best pizza in Jamestown NY! If you’re ever in town be sure to stop by – you won’t be disappointed!

#9 Little Caesars Pizza

The spices used in their pizza are out of this world. The sauce is garlicky and the cheese is melted to perfection. The crust has an amazing crunch when you bite into it that truly elevates the whole experience.

The variety of toppings is also quite impressive. They have everything from mushrooms and onions to pineapple and green peppers. On top of that, with their vast selection, you can find something for everyone in your group!

I must say that I was most impressed by the friendly service I received at Little Caesars Pizza. The staff were always so helpful, accommodating even my pickiest requests, and seemed genuinely concerned about making sure I enjoyed my meal.

All in all, if you’re looking for best pizza in Jamestown NY, Little Caesars Pizza should definitely be at the top of your list!

#10 Domino’s Pizza

My experience there was nothing short of extraordinary. I was immediately greeted by a friendly and helpful customer service representative who made sure I had everything I needed. They even gave me a “special surprise,” which turned out to be some of the best garlic knots I’ve ever had.

The pizza itself was no slouch either! The crust was perfectly cooked and the sauce was flavorful and not too spicy. The cheese coverage was balanced, with just enough to make each bite delicious without being too much.

I also had their special Detroit-style deep dish pizza, which blew my taste buds away. The thick and crispy crust combined so well with all of the ingredients that it became an instant favorite for me.

Overall, Domino’s Pizza is a great place to go for some of the best pizza in Jamestown NY! Whether you’re looking for a quick dinner or a night out with friends and family, this is definitely the place for you.

If you’re willing to go an extra 71 miles, you can get to 29 more pizza places in Niagara Falls!

#11 Pizza Express

I arrived at the restaurant expecting to find nothing more than a typical pizzeria, but I was pleasantly surprised when I saw that it had an inviting atmosphere, with a large open kitchen and a great selection of pizzas. The staff was friendly and helpful, offering up good advice on the wide variety of toppings available.

I ordered a classic Margherita pizza and it arrived piping hot and fresh from the oven! The crust was uniformly thin with just the right amount of thickness so that it didn’t get soggy or break apart. The cheese was nicely melted and the taste of the homemade tomato sauce was delicious.

As for my main course – well, I can say without hesitation that this is some of the best pizza in Jamestown NY! It had such perfect balance of flavors – sweet tomatoes, salty cheese, pungent garlic – all working together in harmony. And if you thought topping choices were limited – order the “Grande Pizza” which has five different toppings (including vegetarian options) – you won’t be disappointed.

The bottom line? Pizza Express is without question one of the top places to get your pizza fix in Jamestown NY! Head there any day of week for consistently delicious pies that will make your taste buds dance with joy!

#12 Bair’s Pizza Inc

The atmosphere and service at Bair’s Pizza Inc was second-to-none. I could tell right away that the staff genuinely cared about making sure my experience was great. That’s a huge plus in my book!

The pizza itself is simply outstanding. The crust is especially noteworthy – it’s perfectly thin and crispy yet still manages to hold together beautifully when you take a slice up with your hands. The sauce and cheese are wonderfully balanced, too, creating an overall flavor profile that I can confidently call the best pizza in Jamestown NY.

Oh, and don’t forget to try some of their signature pizzas like the Calabrian or the Chicken Bacon Ranch – they’re both fantastic!

In short, if you’re looking for an amazing pizza experience in Jamestown NY, then look no further than Bair’s Pizza Inc. You won’t be disappointed!