Home » Best Local Pizza » Best Pizza in St Paul MN (Updated Fall 2023)

Best Local PizzaBest Pizza in Minnesota

Best Pizza in St Paul MN (Updated Fall 2023)

Edward Brock

02/08/2024

221 Views

I must admit, I’d put St Paul low on my list of places to search for the very best pizza, but sometimes the best surprises come from unexpected places.

So I thought I’d give it a shot, and sampled 12 pizza places around town – from the holes in the wall to the gourmet restaurants. And you know what? It was actually quite enjoyable!

My goal was to find the best of the best pizza in St Paul MN. The next few paragraphs will focus on what each place had to offer, and which one comes out as my ultimate winner. Let’s get started!

If you don’t find the best pizza here, check out the best pizza in the whole state of Minnesota

#1 Tommie’s Pizza

The first thing that caught my eye when I walked into the restaurant was the wood-fired oven. Now that’s a sight you don’t see every day! The friendly staff let me have a peek and it was quite impressive.

The pizza selection was also impressive. They offer something for everyone, from classic Margherita to spicy pepperoni. Every pizza I tried was cooked to perfection in the wood-fired oven, making it just crisp enough without being too dry or over-done. Not to mention, the taste was divine!

What really sets Tommie’s Pizza apart is their unique toppings. You can get everything from artichoke hearts to pine nuts on your pizza! With such an extensive topping list, you’re sure to find something new every time you visit this quaint pizza joint.

To top it all off (no pun intended), the prices were surprisingly affordable. It felt like I got my money’s worth and then some! It’s no wonder people come back here again and again – who doesn’t love great tasting pizza at an amazing price?

If you’re looking for the best pizza in St Paul MN, there’s no better place than Tommie’s Pizza.

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Minneapolis!

#2 Doge Pizza

The atmosphere of the restaurant is simply amazing. The décor is modern and slimy, with minimalist elements that make it feel cozy and inviting. Even the music was great – it felt like a chill jazz club!

As for the pizza, I’m still drooling just thinking about it. When they say they have ‘the best pizza in town’, they really mean it! Crusts are perfectly crispy and thin, yet substantial enough that you can pick up a slice without having to worry about breaking it in half. The toppings were fresh and generous; no measly portions here. In fact, I was hard pressed to finish my entire slice!

I also had a chance to sample some of their appetizers and desserts, which I must say were excellent as well. They even offer gluten-free options if you’re looking for something special!

Overall, I highly recommend Doge Pizza for anyone looking to enjoy the best pizza in St Paul MN. Their combination of delicious food, excellent service and great atmosphere will make this restaurant your new favorite go-to spot for some delectable ‘za!

#3 Pino’s Pizzeria

The first time I walked into Pino’s, I was immediately taken aback by its cozy atmosphere. From the warm and inviting decor to the friendly staff, Pino’s really has the perfect vibe for pizza lovers.

When it comes to their pies, Pino’s definitely knows what they’re doing! The thin crust is cooked perfectly and is loaded with delicious toppings. Each bite is a flavor explosion that will have your taste buds dancing in delight. And then there’s the marinara sauce…simply divine!

I can honestly say that ordering a pizza from Pino’s will be one of the best decisions you’ll make all week (or maybe even month!), especially when it comes to finding some of the best pizza in St Paul MN!

#4 Mama’s Pizza

Having been to some of the most renowned pizza places around the globe, I consider myself a pizza connoisseur. I was ready to be underwhelmed when I arrived at Mama’s Pizza, but that couldn’t have been further from the truth.

The atmosphere of Mama’s Pizza is cozy and comfortable. The decor is warm and inviting, and you’ll quickly feel like part of the family. Not only that, the employees were genuinely friendly and attentive – they even remembered my name after just one visit!

Of course, it’s all about the pizza here – and boy did they deliver! Every single bite was bursting with flavor. The crust was perfectly crisp outside with a soft and chewy inside. Toppings were generous yet balanced – none overpowered the rest. The cheese and sauce blended perfectly in such harmony, it was almost like a symphony for your taste buds!

In my opinion, Mama’s Pizza is hands down some of the best pizza in St Paul MN – maybe even all of Minnesota! Whether you’re looking for a relaxing atmosphere for dinner or simply need a quick slice on-the-go during your lunch break, Mama’s Pizza has something for everyone. If you haven’t tried Mama’s Pizza yet, go do it now; you won’t regret it!

#5 The Pizza Shop West St Paul

This little gem is a great place for vegetarians and carnivores alike. I’m always on the hunt for places that offer options free of meat, and The Pizza Shop West St Paul did not disappoint!

The pizza is, in a word… delicious! The crust has just enough crunch to it, and the sauce is flavorful without being overpowering. Toppings are fresh and plentiful, making each bite burst with flavor.

The only downside is that they don’t offer delivery; you have to come in to experience this deliciousness. But trust me – it’s worth it! When you need the best pizza in St Paul MN, look no further than The Pizza Shop West St Paul.

#6 Mario’s

I was enthralled by the rich and savory marinara sauce that Mario’s uses on their pies. It has a deep, robust flavor that rivals any pizza I’ve tasted in Italy or New York. But there’s no need to take a fancy plane ride to find top-tier pizza – Mario’s is here in St Paul!

The crust is cooked just right – crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. And most importantly for me, the cheese ratio is spot-on – not too runny, not too rubbery. All ingredients are clearly fresh and of high quality, making for an absolutely delightful pizza-eating experience.

As if their pizzas weren’t great enough, they also offer a variety of unique toppings like artichoke hearts, pineapple, and spicy roasted garlic that really drive home the flavors. Plus they even have vegan options!

What could be better? Well how about fast delivery times? At Mario’s you can expect your order to show up quickly and piping hot.

For me it doesn’t get any better than Mario’s Pizza – some of the best pizza in St Paul MN!

#7 Mavericks Pizza

When I first walked in, I was struck by the funky decor. The cool rock ‘n’ roll inspired artwork and an eclectic mix of old-school records playing on the jukebox set just the right tone for an amazing pizza experience.

The pizza is certainly top-notch here. From their thin-crust Neapolitan pies to their classic New York-style pies, they know how to make a delicious pizza. All of them came out perfectly cooked with a nice char on the homemade dough and beautiful bubbling cheese atop. Plus, they offer over 20 unique toppings ranging from traditional favorites to creative takes on flavors like truffled mushrooms and bacon bits!

Their service is friendly and efficient, which makes dining in at Mavericks Pizza a great experience. Whether you’re eating in or taking it home, they get your order done fast so you can enjoy your meal immediately.

I would highly recommend Mavericks Pizza to anyone seeking the best pizza in St Paul MN. Their combination of quality ingredients and distinctive flavor make for an unforgettable pizzeria experience!

#8 Punch Pizza Grand Avenue

I was a bit skeptical when I first walked in the door. After all, there’s no delivery option. However, the moment I stepped inside and laid eyes on the menu I knew this place was special. They have vegan options and a kid’s menu – perfect for my picky eaters!

But the best part? The pizza! It was cooked to perfection with just the right amount of crunch and flavor – simply delicious! On top of that, they offer desserts and serve alcohol as well. What more could you ask for?

Overall, Punch Pizza Grand Avenue is definitely a great spot if you’re looking for awesome pizza in St Paul MN. Plus, it makes for a nice tourist spot too! Highly recommended!

If you’re willing to go an extra 6 miles, you can get to 30 more pizza places in Minneapolis!

#9 Carbones Pizza

I recently visited Carbones Pizza while in the area and they did not disappoint. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile from the staff and an amazing aroma of freshly cooked pizza that quickly made my mouth water.

The atmosphere of the restaurant was friendly and inviting, perfect for sharing a few slices with friends or grabbing a quick bite on the go. The food selection was also impressive; ranging from classic pizza recipes like pepperoni and cheese to creative combination styles like sausage, black olives, and jalapeno peppers.

When it came time to sample their pizza, there were no surprises — it tasted as delicious as it smelled! The crust was perfectly crispy and the toppings were flavorful without being overwhelming. In fact, what made this pizza stand out more than anything else was its incredible balance between flavors and textures; it truly left me wanting more after every bite!

If you’re looking for some of the best pizza in St Paul MN, Carbones Pizza should definitely be at the top of your list. With its fresh ingredients, friendly atmosphere and delicious recipes, Carbones Pizza is sure to satisfy your cravings for a great slice of pizza!

#10 Angelo’s Pizza

I’ve had great pizza in Rome, Naples and even New York City – but Angelo’s Pizza may just have topped them all! From the first bite, I knew that this was something special. The blend of cheeses, the perfect thin crust, and perfectly savory sauce combined for a pizza that was simply delicious.

The atmosphere at Angelo’s Pizza is just as memorable. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, you can always expect a warm welcome and a smile from their friendly staff. And don’t forget about their famous garlic knots – they are THE BEST!

If you haven’t already been to Angelo’s Pizza I highly recommend it. It just might be the best pizza in St Paul MN!

#11 Red’s Savoy Pizza

I was taken aback when I first walked in, by the bright and lively décor. It had an old-school feel to it, which I absolutely loved. Plus, the people at the restaurant were incredibly friendly.

As far as the pizza goes, Red’s Savoy Pizza definitely serves up amazing pies. The dough was cooked perfectly – not too doughy, but still soft and light. The toppings were fresh and flavorful, and they just melted in my mouth! I’m a big fan of their speciality pizzas – ‘The Edge’ is my favorite – with the extra cheesy crust & yummy garlic butter sauce on top!

All in all, if you’re looking for some delicious pizza in St Paul MN, look no further than Red’s Savoy Pizza! It really lives up to its reputation of being the best pizza in St Paul MN.

#12 Skinner’s

When I first walked into Skinner’s, I was immediately filled with the anticipation of trying some of the best pizza in St Paul. I took a look around and noticed that the restaurant was surprisingly homey and cozy. The delicious smells coming from the kitchen were an added bonus.

My mouth was already watering when my server brought out my one topping pizza – it looked amazing! After taking a bite of the first slice, I knew why Skinner’s is known as having some of the best pizza in town. The crust had just the right amount of crunchiness while still having a slight pillowy texture to it, plus it was cooked perfectly golden brown! The sauce was flavorful but not overly spicy, which was great for me since I’m not a fan of spicy food.

To top it all off, Skinner’s has super friendly staff that are always willing to go above and beyond to make sure you have an enjoyable experience. If you’re ever looking for some great pizza in St Paul MN, definitely check out Skinner’s – they serve up some of the best pizza in town!

Best Deep Dish Pizza – The Italian Pie Shoppe

Now, I’ve had my fair share of pizza, from the rolling hills of Naples to the bustling streets of New York, but nothing compares to the heavenly creation served up at The Italian Pie Shoppe. As soon as I walked in, the smell of melted cheese and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce hit me like a delicious slap in the face. It’s a good thing I had a reservation, because this place is always packed with pizza enthusiasts.

Let’s talk about the crust, or should I say, the foundation of happiness. It’s thick, buttery, and crispy on the outside, yet delightfully soft on the inside. Each slice is like a little slice of heaven, and I’ve seriously contemplated ordering an entire pie just for myself. Don’t judge me, okay? We all have our pizza cravings.

The toppings are another level of perfection. From the perfectly melted mozzarella to the generous portions of savory Italian sausage, every bite is bursting with flavor. I don’t know what kind of wizardry they use in their kitchen, but I suspect it involves a sprinkle of magic dust and a whole lot of love.

But here’s the best part: they don’t scrimp on the cheese. I’m talking about gooey, stretchy, pull-it-off-your-face strings of cheesy goodness. It’s like they’ve discovered the secret formula for happiness and it involves a riveting cheese-to-pizza ratio.

So if you’re after the best deep dish pizza in the twin cities, head straight to The Italian Pie Shoppe. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you. And who knows, you might just start contemplating moving in because it’s that good.